Hirokami threatens to leave if orchestra reduced
Checking in on the dire situation in Columbus, Adaptistration is reporting that music director Junichi Hirokami is opposed to downsizing the Columbus Symphony Orchestra as part of a restructuring plan. (Take a look at some of the links to stories about the crisis, as well as the musicians Web site.)
The blame is being placed on board members for failing to raise money or community support (see the post below this, as well, for a brief summary.)
"Any downsizing of the orchestra would be "catastrophic," Junichi Hirokami said. "If the orchestra is reduced, I have no purpose to stay here."
Cincinnati has a large pool of excellent freelance musicians, and Columbus employs about 10 local musicians on a regular basis. Many of them, you'll also hear locally in the Cincinnati Chamber Orchestra, Kentucky Symphony, Cincinnati Ballet Orchestra, Dayton Philharmonic, subbing in the Cincinnati Symphony Orchestra and elsewhere around the region.
Cincinnati cellist Tom Guth writes, "I've played up in Columbus for 10 years, and have noticed the change in crowds, attitude, reduction of players. ... I kind of felt they were already down to a minimum of players and would have to cut weeks -- not weeks and core players."
Violinist Manami White says "It's quite shocking, appalling and demoralizing that this is happening. I am quite sure that if they cut the number of full-time players stated, that there will be no work for us, the commuting musicians.
"What will the public do when there are no more arts organizations around? Will they miss it?" she asks.
11 Comments:
One of the musicians laments what will the public do when there are no arts organizations around...will they miss it? It seems as though since it was previously reported that ticket sales for this orchestra were disappointing (I would take that as declining)it seems as though their audience (customers) have voted with their feet and found other things to do. Larger orchestras, especially one very large local one, you better take note.
In response to the person who said people are "voting with their feet" I'd like to say that you have to be careful how you judge failures in ticket sales. If the community sentiment is to NOT support a well-functioning organization that's legitimate but if ongoing PR and marketing failures cripple sales then the data is not conclusive. The Columbus Symphony has failed for many years in this regard so the judgements based ticket sales do not necessarily indicate community sentiment for abandoning the organization.
I'll leave the reason why people are not attending to those who are close to the situation. If people are not coming, no matter what the reason or who is responsible, the bottom line is an empty seat generates zero interest and zero revenue. Not a real good long term course of action as they are now experiencing. Survival expections start diminishing exponentially. I didn't mean to imply that people are "abandoning" the organization. What I said is that they have found other things to do. Once that happens it is tough to get them back.
I just don't undersand how the musicians B***hing and complaining about how the board and management are the cause of this issue solves anything. I work for a bank and the mortgage crisis is causing us major income issues, but instead of pointing the finger at management, my fellow employees and I try to SOLVE the problem so we can keep our jobs. Do the musicians have any plan or have they taken any action to HELP vs just complaining. Do they expect to show up and get paid because they have some special privilege for which jobs should be provided to them? If I take that attitude at my job, then I become PART OF THE PROBLEM. The prospect of a 31 piece orchestra is amusing by the way. That will kill the group.
Musicians of the Columbus Symphony, stop pointing fingers and start trying to help!
I don't think they intend to play Mahler or Bruckner with a 31 piece band, but rather with 31 FT in-house musicians filled out with subcontracted freelance musicians. If you've ever been in a church choir with paid professional section leaders, then you have an idea what might be coming. And agreed, this will definitely put a hit on quality...
This is a really alarming situation--for all orchestras everywhere.
Hirokami is in a really tough position.
To the reader who posted a comment on 1/23/2008 @ 12:54PM, according to the existing collective bargaining agreement between the musicians and management, the musicians already do quite a bit to help with fundraising efforts. One item requires the musicians to donate four services for major fundraising events each season. Furthermore, the management can request the musicians donate additional services, which is then put to the orchestra for a majority vote. Consequently, that one item is just a single example of how the musicians and management do work together in order to find solutions to fundraising problems. As such, this clearly demonstrates that the musicians have taken action to help versus just complaining.
~ Drew McManus
It's obvious the Columbus Symphony board is bent on cutting so they aren't likely to be raising funds, just to prove their point. Who will be buying subscriptions next year for this economically "improved" symphony? Failure is built in, and that's success to those who wish to make the case for cutting. Just drive right past Columbus and head to Cincinnati or Cleveland.
There isn't an art museum out there that could rely on attendence alone to cover the costs of staying open... Maybe we should close 'em all up. There isn't a ballet company out there that lives on ticket revenue...let's close those up too. Or better yet, maybe they should only perform the Nutcracker all year. Yes, that's it, the Columbus Symphony should only play the 5th symphonys of a couple of the great composers, then the Board won't have to be responsible to the community.
Sad to hear the comments on closing up the entire Columbus Orchestra--has anyone tried to scout the city, as Cincinnati music lovers do, to come up with some very financially proven families. One name comes to us, Schottenstein, the family who has given so much to that city's
entire community, and wonder if anyone did go to ask them to help?
How happy they might be to have a part in saving such a musical gem....
Anyone in Columbus should read us..........
Jenelle,
I've written a letter to Columbus about the Symphony crisis. I hope you can take a minute and read it.
Feel free to pass it on to others. Also feel free to quote it on your blog or even submit it to the Inquirer. If you suggest I do it, please let me know.
Columbus needs to come together to solve this crisis.
I posted the letter on my blog, Buzzing Reed. Feel free to comment on it there. The link to it is:
Letter to the Citizens and Leadership of Columbus
Respectfully,
David Thomas
Principal Clarinet
Columbus Symphony Orchestra
* Our online blogs currently are hosted and operated by a third party, namely, Blogger.com. You are now leaving the Cincinnati.Com website and will be linked to Blogger.com's registration page. The Blogger.com site and its associated services are not controlled by Cincinnati.Com and different terms of use and privacy policy will apply to your use of the Blogger.com site and services.
By proceeding and/or registering with Blogger.com you agree and understand that Cincinnati.Com is not responsible for the Blogger.com site you are about to access or for any service you may use while on the Blogger.com site.
<< Home